Welcome new subscribers of Real-World AI for Teachers! My work this summer has increased the numbers of educators who have subscribed to this newsletter, and I’m excited to continue providing my curated collection of news stories and classroom-tested lessons to so many teachers. I appreciate you putting your trust in me!

News and Updates

Parents Want AI Literacy, Google Bundles AI with Search, Anthropic for Teachers Get Privacy

Google Gives Schools More Control Over AI—With a Catch

Education Week reports that Google will begin turning off Gemini and Google Search by default for K–12 student accounts unless district administrators choose to enable them. But there’s an interesting wrinkle: schools can’t turn on traditional Google Search without its AI features. Google says its school version of AI-powered Search will emphasize guided, step-by-step learning rather than simply providing answers.

I think this highlights just how difficult the idea of “turning off AI” is becoming. AI is increasingly woven into tools students already use rather than sitting inside a clearly labeled chatbot. For schools, the question may soon be less about whether students have access to AI and more about which AI experiences we want them to have, at what ages, and for what purposes.

Anthropic Agrees to Stronger Privacy Protections for Teachers

Anthropic has agreed to contractually enforceable privacy and safety protections for districts using Claude for Teachers. Among other provisions, educator and student data generally cannot be used to train AI models, unnecessary data collection must be minimized, and districts are expected to keep humans involved in high-stakes decisions such as grading, discipline, and student placement.

Microsoft adopted similar protections earlier this fall, so I’m encouraged to see this becoming something of a trend. As schools adopt more AI tools, privacy and human oversight shouldn’t be bonus features buried somewhere on page 47 of the terms of service. The more educators and districts expect these protections, the more likely they are to become standard.

Parents Want AI Literacy—and Some Pretty Strong Guardrails

A new National Parents Union survey found that 77% of parents want public schools to teach students how to use AI effectively, while 85% want schools to teach AI safety. At the same time, 71% support banning student use of AI chatbots during the school day, and 81% oppose schools buying technology that hasn’t been shown to be safe and effective for learning.

Those numbers may sound contradictory at first, but I don’t think they are. Parents seem to be saying that AI literacy and unlimited AI access are two very different things. We can prepare students for a world full of AI while still being thoughtful about when they should use it—and when wrestling with a difficult problem on their own is exactly what they need.

AI-Supported Lesson of the Month

Predict Before You Prompt

One of the easiest ways AI can interfere with learning is by showing up too early.

If students ask AI for an explanation or solution before they have tried the task themselves, they lose the chance to see what they already understand and where they are stuck.

That’s why I like a simple routine called Predict Before You Prompt.

It connects directly to one of the ideas in The Learning Forge: Try First.

Before students ask AI anything, they make a prediction, solve the problem, explain the concept, interpret the evidence, or otherwise commit to their own thinking.

Then they bring AI into the process.

Start With Your Own Thinking

Before using AI, students answer a question like:

  • What do I think the answer is?

  • What do I predict will happen?

  • How would I solve this?

  • How confident am I?

The principle is simple:

AI comes second.

That order matters. If AI gives the first answer, students are mostly reacting to someone else’s thinking. If they begin with their own idea, they have something to defend, revise, or reconsider.

Then Compare

Once students have recorded their thinking, they can ask AI for an explanation or alternative response.

Then ask them to compare:

  • What did the AI notice that I missed?

  • Where did we agree?

  • Did I change my mind?

  • What evidence caused me to change—or not change—my answer?

That is where the metacognition happens.

Students are paying attention not just to the answer, but to how their own thinking changes.

Add a Confidence Check

A simple extension is to have students rate their confidence before and after using AI.

❝

Before AI: My answer is ________. Confidence: 3/5
After AI: I would keep/change my answer because ________. Confidence: 4/5

Sometimes confidence will go up. Sometimes it will go down.

Both can be useful.

Try It Tomorrow

Take a question you already planned to ask and add one rule:

Students must record their own thinking before opening an AI tool.

Then give them a prompt like:

❝

Here is my answer to the question below. Do not simply tell me whether I am right or wrong. Give me an alternative explanation, identify anything I may have overlooked, and ask me one question that would help me think more carefully.

Why I Like This Approach

AI can be useful for offering explanations, alternatives, and feedback.

But if it arrives too early, it can replace the productive struggle students need.

Predict Before You Prompt protects that first round of thinking.

Students try first, commit to an idea, and then use AI as something to compare against.

That reinforces a habit I want students to carry beyond any single assignment:

Before you ask AI what it thinks, make sure you know what you think.

Want to see more? Check out the Learning Forge One-Pager for more ideas from the upcoming book.

Upcoming Talks and Appearances

Where is Paul this month?

This month brought Paul to the annual conference of the Association for Middle Level Education in Nashville, and short tour of possible publishers for The Learning Forge. And that’s it for travel until January.

That’s it for this month.

November’s newsletter will include a shout out to the folks I’m most thankful for this year.

Paul (and the Codium Educational Consulting team)

P.S.

Don’t forget to email me with examples of how you’ve used the tools and strategies that I’ve shared.